Amy MariettaExploring the Best Independent Jewelers in NYC
New York City, a global fashion hub, boasts a wide range of jewelry options. Whether you’re searching for the perfect engagement ring, treating yourself to something elegant, or marking a special occasion, these independent jewelers offer unique, one-of-a-kind pieces. From avant-garde designs to timeless classics, these boutiques feature everything from gold hoop earrings to custom engagement rings and more. Let’s dive into some of the best places to shop for fine jewelry across the city.
JewelryNest
JewelryNest, founded by Evyatar Rabbani, has been a trusted name in handcrafted jewelry for over 35 years. Starting in New York’s iconic 47th Street Diamond District, then moving to the Upper West Side, and finally launching one of the first handmade jewelry e-commerce stores in 1998, they have redefined affordable luxury. Known for offering the finest handcrafted jewelry made with high-quality diamonds and gemstones, they eliminate the middleman, offering customers a streamlined, direct-to-consumer experience. The brand is known for its beautifully crafted gold hoop earrings in NYC and engagement rings, with a global reach including the U.S.A., Canada, and the European Union. They pride themselves on customer satisfaction, providing a risk-free, enjoyable shopping experience.
141 Woodmere Blvd, Woodmere, NY 11598
Marisa Perry Atelier
Located at the corner of Hudson and Horatio Streets in the West Village, Marisa Perry Atelier offers an intimate, homey atmosphere that makes it feel more like visiting friends than a jewelry store. Founded in 2002 by Marisa Perry and designer Douglas Elliott, the atelier is known for its exceptional customer service and beautiful designs, many of which have earned accolades in top fashion publications. The atelier specializes in custom designs, from engagement rings and wedding bands to cufflinks and more, in addition to their own signature jewelry collection.
636 Hudson St., New York, NY 10014
Greenwich St. Jewelers
Family-owned since 1976, Greenwich St. Jewelers has been a trusted name in the jewelry world. Now run by sisters Jennifer and Christina Gandia, the store moved to its flagship location on Reade Street in Tribeca in 2022. With a design inspired by mid-century aesthetics—think light wood and brushed marble—the space is as stylish as the pieces it carries. You’ll find a variety of designer jewelry here, but if you’re looking for something truly personal, the shop also offers custom design services for engagement rings and unique creations. They’re also experts in repairs, restoration, and redesign.
93 Reade St., New York, NY 10013
Mociun
Brooklyn’s Mociun, founded by designer Caitlin Mociun, draws influence from Bauhaus design principles to create sleek, minimalist pieces with an unexpected elegance. Specializing in fine jewelry, from engagement rings to earrings, Mociun’s designs are as artistic as they are beautiful, with some pieces crafted from rare, one-of-a-kind materials. In addition to jewelry, the Williamsburg store offers a curated collection of home goods and gifts. While walk-ins are welcome, custom designs require an appointment.
683 Driggs Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11211
Catbird
For two decades, Catbird has been a Williamsburg staple, offering minimalist yet elegant jewelry with a commitment to sustainability. Founded in 2004, the brand is known for its “jewelry as poetry” philosophy, creating pieces that are as wearable as they are beautiful, with ethically sourced gold and conflict-free stones. Catbird’s range includes stackable rings, tennis necklaces, whimsical charms, as well as engagement and wedding rings, and a men’s collection. They’ve also collaborated with notable figures like Phoebe Bridgers and Jenny Slate.
108 N 7th St., Brooklyn, NY 11249
The Seven
One of the newest additions to NYC’s independent jewelry scene, The Seven opened its doors in 2022 and quickly made a name for itself. Located in an eclectic space that also features luxury perfumes, home décor, and fashion, the store showcases some of the most unique and limited-edition jewelry you’ll find in the city. Owner Camille Zarsky has curated a collection of one-of-a-kind pieces from global designers, including a 14k gold pendant with Ethiopian opal, diamonds, and turquoise by Mason & Books. The store also offers custom jewelry design in a pink velvet VIP room.
28 Harrison St., New York, NY 10013
Martin Busch Jewelers
Since 1954, Martin Busch has been a beloved family-run jewelry shop known for its custom designs, especially engagement rings. Located in the Financial District, the shop offers a welcoming atmosphere and a staff that treats you like family. Martin Busch also specializes in repairs, making it a go-to for anything from minor fixes to major restorations. Walk-ins are welcome, though appointments are recommended for custom services.
85 John St., New York, NY 10038
Page Sargisson
For those who appreciate bold, unconventional designs, Page Sargisson’s pieces are a perfect fit. Specializing in one-of-a-kind, freeform stones, Sargisson’s jewelry blends color, texture, and ethically sourced materials. Her Boerum Hill shop is where the magic happens—each piece is handmade on-site, so you can watch as the jewelry comes to life. Whether you’re looking for a custom engagement ring or a unique wedding band, Sargisson creates designs that are both fresh and timeless.
347 Atlantic Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11217
Briony Raymond
With a background at Van Cleef & Arpels, Briony Raymond established her studio in 2015 and quickly became known for her exquisite estate jewelry and bespoke pieces. Her offerings range from vintage-inspired designs to modern reinterpretations, including stunning engagement rings and one-of-a-kind items. Raymond’s jewelry has caught the attention of A-listers like Rihanna and Sarah Jessica Parker. Services are by appointment only, and can be conducted virtually or in her New York studio.
Doyle & Doyle
For over 25 years, sisters Elizabeth and Irene have curated a stunning collection of vintage and antique jewelry at Doyle & Doyle. Specializing in both rare estate finds and bespoke creations, they offer an array of unique pieces, including vintage engagement rings and men’s jewelry like cufflinks and signet rings. Their work has been featured in Vogue and Harper’s Bazaar, and their attention to detail makes each piece a part of fashion history. Appointments are necessary to view their collection, whether in person or virtually.
41 Union Square W, New York, NY 10003
Final Thought:
New York City’s independent jewelers offer more than just a chance to buy something beautiful—they provide an experience. Whether you’re looking for the perfect gold hoop earrings, a custom engagement ring, or a unique piece to mark a special occasion, these boutiques and ateliers are dedicated to offering high-quality craftsmanship and personalized service. From established names with decades of history to new, cutting-edge designers, there’s something for every taste and budget. So, the next time you’re in the city, take a moment to explore these gems—you’re bound to find a piece that’s as extraordinary as the city itself.